Carl G. Elias is the leader of an organized crime syndicate intent on reuniting the five Italian mob families and taking over the organized crime business in New York. His secondary goal is to remove the growing Russian mob influence from Brighton Beach.
In 1973, eight-year-old Carl Elias discovers the body of his murdered mother, Marlene Elias.
Some time afterwards, Elias lives in a group home with Anthony Marconi and Bruce Moran among others, the three being close friends but being treated to harsh discipline. (“The Devil You Know”) Elias eventually enters the foster system, and eventually moves in with his foster mother, Gloria Recinto, a manicurist. In 1981, he is treated for wounds sustained during a fight which broke out after another child called him a bastard.
Recinto is a loving foster mother who treats Elias well. When he is assigned a project researching his family tree, he asks his foster mother if she is willing to help him research his father. Knowing who he is, she encourages him to let it go. Elias feels like he has no identity, but Recinto teaches him that he can create his own identity rather than getting it from the family he never knew. It was to become a critical lesson in his life. (“Flesh and Blood”)
Despite his foster mother's urgings, Elias wants to know who his father is, believing he can be part of a family. In 1991, Elias meets his father, Don Gianni Moretti, a mafia Don with whom his mother had an affair, at a restaurant. Moretti recognizes his illegitimate son and promises Elias a place in his organization as long as he remains loyal, tenacious, and capable. Behind Elias's back, Moretti dismisses him as the throw-away son of one of his women on the side.
Elias begins working in Moretti's organization, learning the ropes, and is eager to earn his approval. Although he appears to be advancing in the ranks, in time, Elias discovers that Moretti has lied to him, and had ordered his execution. He is taken into the woods by two of Moretti's hit men, but Elias fights back, killing his executioners and escaping, sustaining a wound which creates a scar across the palm of one of his hands when he grabs the garrote around his throat. (“Flesh and Blood”) The experience solidifies Elias's determination to seek revenge against the father who denied him.
Emergence as a Mob FigureEdit
In 2011, Elias is living in quiet anonymity, solidifying his power base behind the scenes. Reese and Finch first become aware of Elias when he hires Sam Latimer and his team, including an undercover Reese, to steal a file box labeled "Elias, M." from the NYPD records office.
This file contains the evidence and investigation records into the murder of Marlene Elias, including the murder weapon, a kitchen knife. Latimer delivered the file, but is killed, presumably by Elias or his deputy. (“Mission Creep”)
After Elias acquires the file, he learns his mother was killed by former mobster Vincent DeLuca, and decides to seek revenge. He arranges the stabbing death of DeLuca with the same knife DeLuca used to kill Elias' mother.
Later, when Elias realizes that retired detective Bernie Sullivan, who investigated his mother's murder, is back on the case, Elias has him killed. However, Elias is unaware that Sullivan was in communication with Detective Joss Carter until she arrives at Sullivan's home, finding his body. A shootout occurs, leaving Elias's blood at the scene, the first clue to his identity Carter finds. (“The Fix”)
Reese comes into direct contact with Elias while he is living under the identity "Charlie Burton". As part of his Burton identity, Elias becomes a high school history teacher in Brighton Beach. He spends several years living among the Russian families in Brighton Beach, studying the families of his students associated with organized crime. His number is generated when he is pursued by the rival Yogorov crime family, thinking he is the witness to the shooting of a Russian mafia figure. When Reese meets Charlie Burton, he is unaware of his actual identity.
Burton and Reese become fast friends while trying to escape from the Yogorov family hit-men. With Finch's help, they escape Brighton Beach having captured one of the Yogorov sons. Only then, on a ferry to Manhattan, does Reese learn Burton's true identity and his plans to reunite the Italian mafia families. He forces Reese to tie himself up and leaves the scene with one of his associates, Anthony Marconi, then known only as Scarface. Elias is later seen escaping with his men as he describes his goal to reunite the five families. (“Witness”)
Solidification of PowerEdit
Elias remains quiet for a time, until be becomes a possible threat when Carter's number comes up. Elias hires Carter's confidential informant Bottlecap to kill her, but Reese is able to save her. Elias signs his work by leaving a vase of flowers on Carter's desk with a message mourning her loss before stealing his case file from her desk. (“Get Carter”)
After a dormant period, Elias is implicated as the financier behind the Tritak investment scam, which the team exposes. Reese contacts Elias using a phone left in a trash can by Scarface, who is impersonating a police officer, and who later kills a criminal working for the SEC making it appear to be a suicide.(“Risk”)
Elias's main goal is to seek revenge against his imprisoned father and his half-brother, the Don's heir apparent. Upon his father's release from prison, Elias orders some of his men to kidnap the old Don. His plan fails when Carter and Reese intervene and take Moretti into protective custody.
Reese later calls Elias, requesting his help to find Leila Smith, an infant kidnapped by an Eastern European gang. Elias agrees to help, but threatens the child once Reese finds her. Locked in a refrigerated storage container by Elias, Reese is forced to give up Moretti's location in exchange for Leila's life. Reese tried to protect Moretti, but Elias succeeds in capturing his father. (“Baby Blue”)
Elias's plan to unite the five families requires him to kill the current head of each of them, each of whom has little interest in his plans.
He recruites HR, a cabal of dirty cops, and uses them to help him take down the Dons. After killing one Don with a car bomb planted by Scarface and gunning one Don down in front of Detective Carter, she and Fusco take the remaining three Dons into protective custody, barely escaping Elias's men.
In response, Elias orders the kidnapping of Taylor Carter. He is unaware however, that Finch has shown Officer Simmons, a beat cop in league with HR, photos of Elias's men watching the families of other cops who are part of HR. HR severs its ties with Elias and several clean police officers arrive at the hideout, forcing Elias to surrender. (“Flesh and Blood”)
Life Behind BarsEdit
Elias is taken to Rikers Island, where he is to be held pending trial. After being processed and put in jail, Elias makes one final phone call to Gianni Moretti, telling his father he wishes he could be there to see him. Moretti's car is then blown up by Scarface, killing Moretti and his son Gianni Moretti, Jr.. (“Flesh and Blood”)
Despite being in prison, Elias is still able to run New York's biggest criminal organization. Several weeks later, Elias receives a visit from Finch, who asks for his help with one of the team's cases involving several mafia families and their hit men. Recognizing that Reese and Finch may be useful to him, Elias takes advantage of his power from behind bars and helps them. In return, he asks Finch to play chess with him. (“Triggerman”).
After several more weeks at Rikers Island, Elias encounters Reese, who has been arrested on suspicion of being "The Man in the Suit".
He tells Reese that he knows all about Donnelly's investigation and that he can help Reese, who has been recognized by Byron, the white supremacist from whom he took Bear. When Donnelly moves Reese into the general population in an attempt to get him to reveal his true identity, Reese is attacked by Byron. Reese must allow himself to be beaten rather than reveal his skills as a fighter, leading Elias to break up the fight, protecting Reese. (“Prisoner's Dilemma”)
Breaking with HR Edit
HR approaches Elias in an effort to re-establish their connection, but Elias refuses. As a result, HR joins forces with Peter Yogorov and has many of Elias' men transferred from Rikers Island, making Elias more vulnerable. While playing chess with Finch, Elias reveals his desire to discover the identity of the person who is orchestrating these events. Later, Cal Beecher pays a visit to Elias in prison to learn if Bill Szymanski is on Elias' payroll, as insinuated by Alonzo Quinn. Elias tells Beecher that Szymanski is clean and that Beecher has been played by HR. (“Trojan Horse”)
In retaliation, HR and the Russian mafia have two of Elias's men killed outside a bodega, along with a bystander. Carter later remarks to Reese that the Russians are worse than Elias, having fewer rules and more manpower. (“Zero Day”)
Soon after, one of Elias's lieutenants, possibly Scarface, is shot and taken to the hospital under police guard. Elias immediately arranges for his body guards to be paroled. Instead, he is released on the pretense of a prisoner transfer and taken to the woods by HR member Raymond Terney, who is accompanied by Peter Yogorov, who intend to execute him. Before they can, Carter appears and saves him. He asks Carter where they're going, and she says she doesn't know. (“God Mode”)
Elias, along with Scarface, keep a low profile in a well guarded basement. He bristles at his self-imposed confinement but agrees to keep it a secret from Finch and Reese. He points Carter towards a fence who specializes in uncut diamonds and then sends Scarface to collect the gems after Reese and Shaw engage in a violent shoot out in the fence's shop, indicating he is still manipulating events to his own advantage. (“Liberty”)
Elias, still in his basement sanctuary, provides Carter with a detailed summation of HR's latest money laundering scheme for their ill-gotten revenue. (“The Perfect Mark”)
Carter later calls Elias for another favor. In a restaurant, Elias cooks ravioli for Peter Yogorov, and puts a bullet inside it. An angry Yogorov bursts into the kitchen, where he finds Elias waiting for him. Scarface and several other henchman of Elias hold Yogorov and his partner Nikolai at gunpoint, and Elias explains how he wants to watch HR suffer. His men hand Yogorov some documents containing pictures and information on every member of HR. Elias later calls Carter in a car, telling her that it would've been easier to just kill Yogorov. Carter disagrees before hanging up. (“Endgame”)
When HR puts a hit on Reese, Elias calls Finch to warn him of the bounty, and orders his men to refuse the hit. (“The Crossing”)
Elias temporarily comes out of hiding to visit Simmons in the hospital where he is being held. He says there is a debt to pay for killing Carter, before having Scarface strangle him with a garrote wire. (“The Devil's Share”)
Elias is still hiding out in a basement when Reese comes to visit him, and asks for his help finding a number's kidnapped son. Elias directs him to "The Whale", a heroin shipment coming from Mexico, to a house where the son is likely being held. He also permits Reese to hire him and his assistant, Scarface. (“Panopticon”)
- There are several discrepancies regarding Elias' year of birth and age. The Machine's data, as well as his statement that he was born in 1965 conflicts with other sources of information. Events suggest he was actually born in 1969.
- Elias knows Finch as Harold Crane. (“Triggerman”)
- He is also one of four people whose number has come up more than once since the show began, the other three being Logan Pierce, Leon Tao and Joss Carter. However, Pierce's number came up twice in one episode, while Leon's, Elias' and Carter's have come up across multiple episodes.
Elias either killed or ordered the killing of:
- Two unnamed assassins: killed in self-defense (“Flesh and Blood”)
- Sam Latimer: shot twice in the chest (“Mission Creep”)
- Vincent DeLuca: stabbed in the chest with the same knife Vincent used to kill his mother (“The Fix”)
- Bernie Sullivan: shot to death (“The Fix”)
- Joss Carter: shot while escaping from Bernie's apartment and later tried to have her CI, Bottlecap kill her (“The Fix”) (“Get Carter”)
- Ivan Yogorov's brother: killed by Benny D'Agostino (“Witness”)
- Six unnamed Russian mobsters: killed by Elias' hitmen (“Witness”)
- Ivan Yogorov: shot twice in the chest by his enforcer, Scarface (“Witness”)
- Sydney Baylor: bludgeoned to death by hitman (“Risk”)
- Adam Saunders: attempted to have him killed and framed for Sydney's murder; failed on both ends (“Risk”)
- Doug Rasmussen: shot once in the head by his enforcer, Scarface and made to look like a suicide (“Risk”)
- Two unnamed bodyguards: both killed by Elias' hitmen (“Baby Blue”)
- Taylor Carter: abducted by Elias' men; rescued (“Flesh and Blood”)
- Unnamed security guard: shot to death by Scarface (“Flesh and Blood”)
- The Mafia Don Massacre (“Flesh and Blood”)
- The first car bombing: four fatalities; committed by Scarface
- Three unnamed bodyguards
- One innocent bystander: injured only
- Basile: shot to death by a hitman
- Luciano Grifoni: attempted to have killed; failed
- The second car bombing: two fatalities; committed by Scarface
- The first car bombing: four fatalities; committed by Scarface
- Detective Bowman: shot once in the heart by hitman (“C.O.D.”)
- Patrick Simmons: garroted to death by Scarface on his orders while he sat and watched (“The Devil's Share”)
- Unknown number of unnamed Brotherhood gangsters: Manipulated them into detonating a bomb disguised as a safe. (“The Devil You Know”)
- Link: In the bombed office, survived with a broken arm. (“The Devil You Know”)